They eat horses, don’t they? Just in time for the holidays (and remarkably coincident with the end of the Fall Meet at Churchill Downs), President Obama last week quietly signed a law passed by congress that lifts the 5-year-old ban on federal funding for horse meat inspections; thereby allowing the sale and consumption of viande de cheval.
And, while it is doubtful that any “Surf & Turf” restaurants here in Louisville will have the audacity to start putting filet d’Mister Ed on the menu, the change in the law may serve to add a sense of urgency to the speed ratings of horses in claiming races, come the Spring Meet.
By allowing the U.S. Department of Agriculture to resume horse meat inspections, the new law will effectively allow the operation of slaughterhouses in the U.S. that butcher horses for human consumption. The last U.S. slaughterhouse that butchered horses closed in 2007. But now, our president wants us to start eating horses again.
Pro-slaughter activist Dave Duquette, president of United Horsemen, predicted to The Huffington Post’s Justin Juozapavicius that domestic horse slaughterhouses could open in 30 to 90 days with state approval, and eventually as many as 200,000 horses a year could be slaughtered for human consumption.
What’s that you say? You find the idea of chowing down on Secretariat a bit repugnant? Well, horse is commonly eaten in many European countries; but since under Mosaic Law horse meat is considered unclean because it conformed to the formula of an animal that was not at the same time cloven-hoofed and cud-chewing, it is generally banned in Islamic and Jewish countries.

Back around 732 A.D., Pope Gregory III (who must have been a horse lover) began a concerted effort to stop the pagan practice of esu equorum, and was responsible for the reluctance of many Nordic people to embrace Christianity for some time; largely because they were reluctant to give up eating horse meat. In some countries the effects of this prohibition by the Catholic Church have lingered, and horse meat prejudices have progressed from taboos to avoidance to abhorrence.
And according to Keith Dane, director of equine protection for The Humane Society of the United States, the horse slaughter process is rife with problems. The FDA and the European Union have banned the use of phenylbutazone in animals raised for food because of its cancer-causing properties, and the drug is as common in American horses as Aspirin is in people. “Americans don't eat horses, and they don't want them inhumanely killed and sent abroad as a high-priced appetizer.” The American Horse Slaughter Prevention Act (S. 1176/H.R. 2966), now pending in congress, would ban slaughter of American horses for human consumption.
Interestingly, during the 2008 campaign, then-candidate Barack Obama said, "Federal policy towards animals should respect the dignity of animals and their rightful place as cohabitants of our environment. We should strive to protect animals and their habitats and prevent animal cruelty, exploitation and neglect.... I have consistently been a champion of animal-friendly legislation and policy and would continue to be so once elected." Obama announced that he had co-sponsored legislation to stop the sale for slaughter of wild free-roaming horses and burros, and signed on as co-sponsor to the bill to ban horse slaughter for human consumption. When asked specifically during the campaign, "Will you support legislation ...to institute a permanent ban on horse slaughter and exports of horses for human consumption," Obama gave an unqualified "Yes."
Learn more: Horses could soon be slaughtered for meat in US (Ky. Post)
Learn more: Stophorseslaughter.com
Contact: Complain to the White House
But, on the other hand: Eathorse.com
---------
Louisville.com's The Arena section features opinions from active participants in the city's politics. Their viewpoints are not those of Louisville.com (a website is an inanimate object and, as such, has no opinions).
I'm shocked the author
I'm shocked the author doesn't understand the law, yet he can rant for multiple paragraphs about it. The law no longer permits federal funding of inspections of horse meat! Bush passed the law allocating funds for horse meat inspection. The law does not condone or endorse horse meat for consumption.
respect to life
I'm really disappointed with this law. We should start joining sustainable campaigns instead of producing more environmental damage. There is so much research proving how eating meat is connected to awful diseases such as cancer, diabetes, high blood pressure. This is a question of human health and the well being of the world.
Horse Meat?
Oh, how awful! I appreciate this article, Mr. Jacques. I had no idea this had happened. As you said Mr. Obama did it in some form of secrecy. I believe the majority of people in the US don't know he's done this or surely the animal rights groups would have been up in arms. I surely hope this meat is kept separate from beef and not end up mixed in with other meats so that we consume it without knowing it. I wouldn't be surprised if that were the case. What a horrible thing, even if Europeans do eat it. Most Amercians (as far as I know) don't.
Meat is Meat
I am a Veg. I do it personally and don't do it for superficial reasons.
We aren't talking about eating children, we are talking about eating animals. Pork, Beef, Chicken, Horse, Dog. Get over yourselves and eat what you want.
I am a veg but I don't like Brussel Sprouts. I don't try to prevent others from eating it. Neither should you.
Wow, it is rare to see an
Wow, it is rare to see an insightful comment like that on an article like this. Cheers to that!
Outraged by this new decision?
It is important that all of us who are angered by this news channel that energy toward gaining support for the American Horse Slaughter Prevention Act. You can read more on HSUS CEO Wayne Pacelle's blog - http://hsus.typepad.com/wayne/2011/12/horse-slaughter-in-us.html and you can take action at https://secure.humanesociety.org/site/Advocacy?cmd=display&page=UserAction&id=5095&s_src=waynesblog
No Horse Meat on this table!!!
One more reason to be a vegetarian! Horses were not put on this earth to be eaten!
Horse slaughter
KY's animal abuse laws need to be strengthened and enforced so that horses and other animals will not be neglected. Horses have been starved here for years when they could have been sent to slaughter and most often by owners who could afford to feed them. As a humane society officer I have seen this happen to horses and even cattle over the years. Slaughter is a cruel way to kill a horse and the auctions and transportation they go through are cruel also.
And whoever said there are an over-population of wild horses does not know the facts. Now with almost constant roundups and removals less than approximately 20,000 wild horses are on our public lands in all the West. They are being wiped out by the BLM and the 1971 Wild Free Roaming Horse and Burro Act is being broken.
Visit www.wildhorsepreservation.org for facts .
Also call D.C. at 202-224-3121 and tell Congress to pass the American Horse Slaughter Prevention Act, H.R.2966/S.1176, NOW . Call the White House at 202-456-1111 also. Horses help make KY and we owe them kindness. Wild horses were used in our wars and helped settle the West and need protection as they are going to slaughter also, I rescued three. PLEASE HELP
America's "wild horses" are feral horses introduced by Spanish
Quote - "And whoever said there are an over-population of wild horses does not know the facts"
Fact is that even one "wild horse" is too many. They don't belong here. They are not indigenous to North America. Spanish explorers brought horses to our continent in the sixteenth century. There were related animals here 10,000 years ago but they were very different and lived in the company of Mastodons, Sabre Toothed Cats, and Ground Sloths.
North America's "wild horses" are really feral horses and, like feral hogs, they upset the natural balance and should be eliminated. Keep them on the ranch but get rid of them in the wild. Just because they look cutesy doesn't mean our "wild horse" ecological calamity should be tolerated any longer. Let hunters harvest them and eat them.
Can you imagine...
Can you imagine how great Barbaro would've tasted?
Horse Lover Who Supports Horse Slaughter
I rarely chime in on politically charged discussions, but I'm afraid this is something I have to speak up on. By shutting down horse slaughter facilities five years ago, the US government condemned unwanted and rescue case horses to immeasurable suffering. They were shipped to Canada and Mexico, where humane slaughter laws are weak or non existent, and they were treated horribly every step of the way only to die terrible, painful, inhumane deaths.
As a horse lover and owner, making horse slaughter legal again is one of the most humane and kind things that can be done to improve the lives of unwanted animals. Plus, the consumption of horse meat in the US is very low and most of it will be exported to foreign countries where the demand is high. The likelihood of livestock farmers in the US being negatively impacted is extremely slim.
And that estimate of 200,000 horses going to slaughter in the US is roughly 1% or less of the total horse population in the country, making it one of the lowest percentages in the world. Signing slaughter back into legality was a good move, the right move, and will prevent the same unspeakable treatment suffered by horses slaughtered cruelly and illegally in the last five years. It's not as if all horses who don't win in the races are being condemned; the horses that will be affected are those that are been neglected, abandoned, and mistreated - the unwanted. At least now they won't be both the unwanted and the grotesquely abused.
This is not a political argument, it is a humane one.
Eating Horses
the horses that will be affected are those that are been neglected, abandoned, and mistreated - the unwanted. At least now they won't be both the unwanted and the grotesquely abused.
This is not a political argument, it is a humane one.
What is next Cats & dogs...homeless people? Just sub the word horses for orphans? I'm from Kentucky. Killing a horse for any reason should be punishable & anyone who who'd eat a hamburger will end up eating horse. It's cheep. Is it as cheep as saw dust & meal worms like McDonalds & Taco Bell use for meat product? It's all about taste & cheep filler. They make a spray for flavor. You will think horse and meat glue is a T-bone.
Um, you're equating horses
Um, you're equating horses and people? Interesting.
Horse Slaughter
Stopping horse slaughter in the US is not the cause of unfed and/or uncared for horses--"It's the economy,stupid." Now that is cleared up: let me ask you: would you want to eat or ship to anyone else to eat, horse meat most likely containing vaccines, wormer, and drug residue???
To continue---what is humane about untrained workers attempting to kill a horse with a bolt gun--often only barely stunning the horse which is then lifted alive by one leg to have its' throat cut and bled out??? When you can tell me this, I will support your point of wiew.
Horses are not for meat
Horses are not for meat production especially in a country where meat is plenty.Horses are no longer for consumption but for performance,therapy,farm production , and for American freedom to roam if wild horses were to be chosen for meat.Many people of this country and others who appreciate,own and recognize horses as an animal not meat.I am no vegan nor vegetarian but a person who works with horses and studies them for over 13 years I have seen the difference these animals can make in people.They have helped mentally handicapped children and adults be able to move and communicate.In a way they never could before.These animals have helped men and women in prisons recover love and trust and what it means for something or someone to be taken care of. America is known for great changes and successes why would we take an animal that has changed so many lives and have carried many natives.Before America was over run by the British the pony's that carried women and children to safety through the bad and the good.This is not a good change in our country but a sad one . Especially when there are so many people who are willing to help these animals for wrongful death.Therefore this will be a dark day where not only will this affect us the people but also hurt the beef and pork farmers and that is not RIGHT !
OK folks. When everybody
OK folks. When everybody gets off their, uh, high horse, and stops automatically hating anything Obama's underlings do, you might want to look a bit deeper.
Horses (out west) are breeding faster than the carrying capacity of the available land (unless we're willing to restrict cattle grazing), and faster than people can be found to adopt them. So we have a problem. What do do with excess horses. (Suggestions anyone?) (Sorry, I live in town where horses are banned as pets.)
In the absence, of alternatives we have to destroy the excess horses. We can either burn them, bury them or use them for things like the pet-food trade. Pet food is inspected (would you want otherwise?). Oh, and of course horses can be rendered for chemicals. ("Roses are red, violets are blue, horses that lose are turned into glue.")
By the way, what DOES happen to the big stables' slow horses?
And just maybe. Maybe. While Obama is trying to deal with the economy, with Pakistan (or AfPak, if you prefer), with the Middle East, with all of the other big issues, just maybe he had absolutely nothing to do with this one. Ya think?
Hmmmm.
Hmmm. WOW Really? The human population is also breeding like there is no tomorrow, and do we dispose of them? No, we don't. We find a humane solution for them to still survive in this world, even though we probably should do something about that.
I agree
I agree with what you said. Humans are over populating the earth. Instead of lifting the ban on horse slaughter, maybe he should have put a ban on how many kids you can have. No one teaches their kids manners anymore anyway. Just the other day I was unable to enjoy my meal at a well know restaraunt because some kid thought it a good idea to keep touching my back and then run his truck on it. All the while his mother never doing anything to discipline him or even say sorry to me. My towns streets are plauged by kids on skate boards who find it okay to skate in the entire road and block traffic. When asked to move they flip you off. You might think me some cranky 80 year old man...but infact I am a 28 year old female. You don't have to be old to know a thing or two about respect. The article even says that horse meat is full of medications that cause cancer. Why is it okay to sell this meat to Europeans? Oh yeah....I know why. So the 1% can make more money.
You feed that excess
You feed that excess population on Horse meat, solving TWO problems at once.
Horse Slaughter
OMG! I have never ever seen such BS.. Obama can not solve any of the real problems so he turns to horses. Please! He needs to focus on bigger issues like jobs. OK, now that I got that out. I happen to support one horse for my very passionate teenager. It is very expensive.. I drive a old car and do without somethings to give to this horse. That being said, horses are not meant for food. The are a mean of transportation, everyone is complaining about global warming and pollution. How about going back in time and utilizing these horses for transportation. I know you all say I am crazy. I am telling you now if we do not change our ways and bow to mother nature we will DIE.. The native knew how important it was to adhere to the earth and it[s needs. We are so stupid, we have to get back to basics is so many ways. With transportation, food, education, family and so much more. Come on... God gave us Earth and all we need our laws are killing us.
Slaughter Is Not Humane
How can slaughter of a horse be humane?Anyone who thinks a horse has an easier time in a slaughterhouse is the US is a fool.I didn't vote for Obama because I never trusted him.He creeped me out while he was running for President.But beyong that problems will arise when people don't know what to do after they can no longer car for a horse.The humane thing to do is have horse retirement farms,where horses can live out their lives or be adopted by a good family.
It's the fault of humans for breeding so many horses to begin with.So don't take out your mistakes on a horse.Any horse owner who thinks horse slaughter is ok is living in a dream world and maybe a bit bipolar about horses.It's a cop out and not a sound answer to the problem.
The only answer is take responsibity to breed fewer horses and get unwanted horses a HOME,a DECENT HOME.
animals
I love eating horses.