Add Event My Events Log In

Upcoming Events

    Food & Drink

     East of Chicago Pizza Open in Middletown
    Print this page

    New pizza joint East of Chicago opened in Middletown yesterday. The Ohio-based chain (slogan: Pizza Done Right) now has its first Kentucky location, thanks to co-owners Greg Wilson and Sean O'Connell. After 39 years in various capacities in the restaurant business, Louisville born-and-bred Wilson wanted to do it his way. He decided on the franchise route and chose to work with East of Chicago because of its menu of hand-made, fresh items. "I like to brag on fresh," he told me.


    This location, at 12416 Shelbyville Road (directly across from the Kroger shopping center in Middletown) is delivery and carry-out only. Wilson already has plans for four more area restaurants, which will include dine-in, as well.

    Chicago-style crust, not surprisingly, is featured, but the menu also includes pan, crispy, thin and loaded (stuffed with cheese and pepperoni) crust styles.


    I tried the Chicago-style crust for my pizza, which though not the super-deep-dish you might expect from the name, did have the buttery flavor in the crust I look for in Chicago style. The cheese and toppings were completely covered with the tomato sauce, as they should be for Chicago style. Those who favor a sweeter sauce, rather than a spicier one, will be pleased. The sausage I chose for a topping also was on the mild side, rather than spicy. All in all, it's a much lighter pizza than I was expecting.


    I also ordered the Buffalo Chicken Salad. The chicken is grilled and the salad is huge -- easily enough for two people to share and feel like they made a healthy choice. I didn't realize a hotter buffalo sauce was a choice and I think got the mild, which was a little light on the pepperiness.

    Baked subs, wings, breadsticks and other sides as well as desserts that I didn't get a chance to try this time around fill out the menu. The peanut butter and jelly dessert pizza, says Wilson, is to die for.

    Photos: Kachina Shaw

    Share On:

    Kachina Shaw's picture

    About Kachina Shaw

    A transplanted Hawkeye, I've now lived in Louisville longer than any other city. Can't live without: my husband and fur babies, coal-black coffee, peanut M&Ms, sunflowers, monthly vacations, books, walking paths, massage and a big purse.

    More from author:

    Upcoming Events

      Event Finder

      Restaurant Finder

      The Weekender

      Subscribe to The Weekender, Louisville's weekly guide for where to go and what to do!

      Louisville Real Estate with Joe Hayden, Your Real Estate Expert!